Weighing Massachusetts’s Ticket Resale Proposals

What fans want is the chance to see their favorite singer or sports team in person—without spending too much money or having to endlessly click refresh in an online ticket queue. And most of the time, things work out OK; many games and concerts have enough available seats to accommodate interested fans without breaking the bank.

But there are frustrating exceptions, when demand for tickets far outstrips capacity and some additional winnowing mechanism is needed. Often, what happens is that venues sell their limited tickets to folks willing to wait the longest or lucky enough to get a winning lottery number. Then some of these early purchasers—including professional ticket brokers—turn around and resell their tickets at higher prices, leaving many fans ticketless and deflated.

And while it's tempting to think that we could get better outcomes with just the right policy intervention, most efforts—like price caps and fee limits—carry a range of known risks and unintended consequences that need to be carefully considered.

In Massachusetts, the Governor and the state Senate have introduced separate proposals to curtail the resale ticket market, potentially including a cap on price increases and a separate limit on the fees that resale platforms can charge.

To better understand the potential impact of these proposals, the Ticket Policy Forum provided a research grant to the Center for State Policy Analysis at Tufts. Reviewing existing scholarship and similar proposals in other places, we found that:

  • There is a core reason that ticket resale is common all around the world. Artists and venues are sometimes reluctant to raise ticket prices, even at superstar events where there are many more fans than seats. This creates inevitable economic pressure for ticket brokers to grab tickets alongside other early buyers—and for both groups to resell their tickets, at market prices, to fans who missed out on early sales.
  • Many states and countries have tried to regulate ticket resale, but even well-intentioned regulation can create new risks. For instance, capping resale prices at 110 percent of the original ticket price—as both the Governor and Senate have proposed—could shift transactions from marketplaces like StubHub or SeatGeek to less controlled and more fraud-vulnerable sites like Craigslist or Facebook Marketplace.
  • The shift to digital ticketing has made enforcement newly challenging. Gone are the old days of printed tickets with clear face values—and scalpers hawking their wares close to venues. Many electronic tickets don't show the original price, and the electronic receipts that buyers receive are easy to alter with AI and other photo editing tools.
  • Some of the current proposals lack essential details. As an example, the Governor caps the price of resold tickets at 110 percent of the original price but doesn't say how to account for taxes and fees.
  • Focusing chiefly on the resale market misses one of the driving challenges for fans, which is the tight control that Ticketmaster wields over initial ticket sales and its ability to set fees with little risk of losing business.